Debate Club: Batman Has No Super Powers. Deal With It.

Earlier this week Chris decided to troll me by posting this ridiculous article about how Batman really does have super powers.  Obviously he was joking, as no one in their right mind could actually believe such nonsense.  That said, in the highly unlikely event that he’s deluded enough to actually believe that drivel, here’s a bulletproof rebuttal of his points.

First off, yes Bruce Wayne is obscenely rich, and yes he has access to a company that coincidentally produces many of the same types of gadgets that would be useful to a vigilante crime-fighter.  That however, absolutely does not constitute a superpower.  There are plenty of rich individuals in this world, from the Donald Trumps and Warren Buffets to the Michael Jordans and Gordon Beckhams.  Some of them have the athletic ability, some have the brains, but have any of them donned the mask and cape and made the carrying out of justice their life’s work?  Nope.  So money doesn’t automatically equal superpower.

That’s not to say that money plays no role in Bruce’s development though.  Sure, if he were born to a middle class family without the means that the Wayne family had, perhaps his life would have been different.  That said, the money gave Bruce as much chance to implode as it did to excel.  It would have been easy to fall prey to drinking, drugs, and a decadent lifestyle, burying the pain in a bottle of pills and whiskey.  Instead though, Bruce Wayne used the means he was given to cultivate what he needed to become the caped crusader.

Sure, Bruce Wayne is physically gifted, he’s an excellent fighter.  Yes, the money played a role in that to the degree that he was able to drop off the face of the earth for years in order to learn plenty of different types of badassery.  The skills he learned though, were in fact…learned.  He didn’t wake up one day with the ability to scale walls, lift a car, or punch a thug through a wall.  Any fighting ability he has is learned, beaten into him, the scars of which he carries to battle every night as he defends Gotham.

If there is one thing that could be said to be even close to a super power, it would be Batman’s intellect.  He definitely was born with some good genes when it comes to the mind.  That said, there are plenty of geniuses out there.  The Riddler, Neil DeGrasse Tyson, Bill Gates, that guy who won Jeopardy like 50 times in a row.  Genius isn’t a superpower, it’s simply a gift given to but a few.

The defining characteristic that makes Batman decidedly powerless is this though; if you were to sneak up on Bruce Wayne while he slept (granted this would be difficult, to be sure) and you shot him in the head, what would happen?  Of course, he’d die…because he’s a normal human.  Superman wouldn’t die.  Wolverine wouldn’t die.

Batman is the best superhero ever created because he’s the best parts of you and me.  Sure he’s smarter, stronger, and wealthier than we’ll ever be, but he’s still essentially, like us.  And above all of that, it’s his will that makes him special.  No spider bite or genetic mutation made him special.  He’s mortal, just like the rest of us.  Every night, he dons his suit and he fights crime to protect and defend the people of his city, and every night he puts himself at great risk, much greater than those other bums who just like to use their cheat codes to win.


3 thoughts on “Debate Club: Batman Has No Super Powers. Deal With It.

  1. It’s not that he’s not exceptional, or that his gadgets aren’t like way over the top awesome, to me it’s more that they can be stolen, taken off, etc… Superman, as the antithesis of Batman, can’t take off any of his super powers (save for some kryptonite). If you shoot Superman in the chest while he’s naked, as opposed to in his suit, the result would be the same. If you shoot Bruce Wayne in the chest, without the suit he would die like any ordinary human. To be honest, that’s really my main point. He’s amazing, for sure, but he’s always in way more danger than Superman, The Hulk, Wolverine, etc… because if he loses his gear, or his identity is found out, he could be as vulnerable as you or I.

    I see your point about his gadgets being very power-like, but my rebuttal would be the same to that as well. As awesome as his suit is, when he takes it off,the “power” is gone. It doesn’t belong to him, it belongs to the suit. To me, powers are something you cannot have taken from you because their part of you.

    PS: This is ridiculous.


  2. I wouldn’t say I trolled you. If you took it personally, that’s YOUR hang up, not mine.

    Also, I see you conveniently didn’t address any of the “powers” that his bat suit and associated gadgetry affords him. Show me a Batman that is JUST a dude who is a skilled fighter with extraordinary intellect and can’t absorb bullets or see through walls or zip up and across buildings with ease or fall off a building and crash through the roof of a car and walk away from it or stretch the definition of gliding to its absolute breaking point – which means he’s essentially flying – and I’ll retract my previous stance. Not to mention that he does ALL of that, night after night, and the worst it does to his body is he wakes up a little sore and with a headache. NFL players say they basically don’t stop hurting until the day before their NEXT game, a week later – and that’s the reason why there is only one NFL game a week – and yet he can keep all that up on a daily basis, AND be back in top form the following night. Nope, not super at all. Regular human dude.

    Also, implying that he deserves extra props for being a billionaire who didn’t “implode” under his own decadence – that’s reaching a bit. Simply not being Lindsay Lohan doesn’t automatically make you a noble character.


Leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s